Featured Card Ranking


Best Card Ranking by Card-Type


Best Monster Ranking by Type


Best Monster Ranking by Attribute


Best Monster Ranking by Level


Best Xyz Monster Ranking by Rank


Best Link Monster Ranking by Link-Num

HOME >  Card Rating List  > カディーン's Yu-Gi-Oh! Card Rating List  > Mystical Refpanel

"Mystical Refpanel" Rating Score by カディーン

Mystical Refpanel ▶︎ Deck 《Mystical Refpanel》
japan カディーン
2023/02/12 22:08
Yugioh Icon
An impressive card that depicts the end of the Yugi VS Jono Civil War.
However, in OCG, it has become a disappointing piece in many ways.
The biggest problem is that the fundamental part of what this card does is not answered by the official rules. Supplementary information such as activation conditions is written on the official website, but as for what will happen as a result, it is an individual answer for each card.
That's no wonder, Yu-Gi-Oh cards don't have an effect that says "target a player". I can't answer what I don't have. The OCG itself is a collector's item that reproduces the card in the works, and it is a card that strongly leaves traces of its origins that he did not think much about actually playing with it.
Diverting from the topic, there were no clearly defined rules for the word "target" in the first Yu-Gi-Oh. It wasn't a problem because it was vaguely inferred from the processing of the original work, but as a result, it sparked a big movement without a clear definition, and even so, Konami, who has an ambiguous stance on the rules, has a problem with the duelists. There is a story that anger exploded and clarified when the text was unified in a hurry. At that time, I didn't see the part that said "target the player", and as a result, this card was also a victim of the rules. As an aside, MtG is a little troublesome because the Japanese translation of any target is different depending on the effect of the card because the target is strict.
Since that would be a problem, the current situation is that it is defined as an effect that transfers "an effect that affects only one player", and the rest is an individual case. It's a waste because of its unique effect, but it can't be helped because it's not in the rules.
URL https://en.yugioh-list.com/reviews/view/169783

Update Information - NEW -